Google vs Facebook vs Yelp vs HomeStars: where should a service business collect reviews?

If you run a local service business, your customers can review you in more than one place. Google, Facebook, Yelp and, in Canada, HomeStars all show reviews, and each one handles them differently. So where should you put your effort?

For a local service business, we'd start with Google. This page explains why, where the others still matter, and one big difference: Yelp asks businesses not to ask for reviews at all.

Google: start here, because of Maps

When someone nearby searches for a plumber, a cleaner or a roofer, Google can show local businesses on a map. Google's "Tips to improve your local ranking on Google" page says: "When a customer searches for a business or place near their location, they'll find local results on Google Maps and Search."

Reviews are part of how those results are ranked. Under the heading "Prominence", the same page says: "Prominence means how well-known a business is. Prominent places are more likely to show up in search results. This factor's also based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have. More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking."

That says "can help", not "will". The same page is also clear that "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." For more on what reviews do and don't do for Maps, see do Google reviews help your business show up in Google Maps?

Google also lets you ask. Its "Tips to get more reviews" page says: "To leave reviews, you can ask customers to visit a Google link or scan a QR code." The rules are about how you ask. Google's Fake & Misleading Content & Reviews policy says merchants may not "Discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers". The same policy says merchants may "Solicit or encourage the posting of content that does represent a genuine experience, without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review." So ask every customer, the same way, and never offer anything in return.

Facebook: reviews show up as Recommendations

On Facebook, reviews show up as Recommendations. Meta's "Recommend a business on Facebook" page says: "You can recommend a business by leaving a review on their Facebook Page." A customer goes to your Page, clicks Reviews, and the page's next step is: "Click Yes to recommend the Page or No to not recommend it."

Recommendations only work if they're switched on. Meta's "Turn Recommendations on or off for your business Page" page says: "Recommendations help customers learn more about your business and may make your Page easier to find in Facebook search." It also warns: "Turning Recommendations off will disable Recommendations and remove the rating and reviews from your Page."

Facebook is worth your time if your customers already find you there. Keep your Page details current and reply to Recommendations. One rule from Meta's recommend page applies to you and anyone who helps manage your Page: "You should not leave a recommendation for a business if you help manage its Page." If you do share your Page with customers, check Meta's current help pages first, and follow the same approach as Google: everyone, the same way, no rewards.

Yelp: be there, but don't ask

Yelp is the exception. Its "Don't Ask for Reviews" page for businesses says: "Don't ask anyone to review your business, be it customers, mailing list subscribers, friends, family, etc."

It also explains why asking can backfire: "Proactively asking for reviews may hurt your Yelp rating because our automated software may not recommend reviews that seem to be prompted or encouraged by the business." Yelp's Content Guidelines say it in one line: "Businesses should never ask customers to write reviews."

So don't ask for Yelp reviews, and don't put a Yelp link in your review requests or follow-ups. The same Yelp page also says: "Don't ask for reviews after requesting customer feedback in other places like surveys or contact forms." Instead, keep your Yelp page details accurate and reply calmly to the reviews you get. Yelp's own advice is that "Your best bet to get positive, unbiased reviews about your business is by providing a high quality, memorable customer experience—without any expectation or encouragement of a review in return."

HomeStars: matters for home services in Canada

If you do renovations, repairs or other home services in Canada, homeowners may look you up on HomeStars. Its reviews work differently from Google's. The HomeStars Reviews Policy says a review can generally only be submitted if "The review is linked to a job posted on our platform by one of our homeowners", the pro was hired for that job through HomeStars, and the homeowner is logged in.

There is also a way to bring in past customers. The same policy says: "We also accept reviews for pros from up to five customers who hired them from outside of our platform. Pros are able to request these reviews from their existing customer base (via their account on our platform), and the customer reviews are sent directly to us." It adds that HomeStars verifies these "by requiring the pro to provide a copy of the paid invoice for the job."

Incentives are out here too. The policy says: "Any fake or incentivised reviews are strictly prohibited."

What not to do on any platform

  • No rewards. Google's tips page says offering "free or discounted goods or services, in exchange for customers to post reviews, change reviews, or remove negative reviews is considered fake & misleading content and is strictly prohibited."
  • No picking and choosing. Ask every customer, not just the ones you think will be pleased.
  • No asking for Yelp reviews. Not by email, not at the door, not in a follow-up.

A simple plan

  • Send your review requests to Google. Ask every customer the same way, after the work is done, with your direct review link. If you need it, see how to get more Google reviews.
  • Keep your Facebook Page and Yelp page accurate, and reply to what comes in.
  • If you're in Canadian home services, set up your HomeStars profile and use its own request tool for past customers.

Asking by email with Rapid Feedback

From your own Gmail or Outlook address, everyone you ask gets your Google review link, and anyone who wasn't happy can also tell you privately, so you can make it right. To see plans, visit the pricing page.

Rapid Feedback helps local service businesses get more Google reviews